Was grandma right?

Was grandma right?

Grandma had advice for everything. Some of it holds up surprisingly well, some has a more tangled history. Here we check it against what research knows today.

TraditionExperienceKnowledge
Grandma said

“Eat carrots and you will see in the dark”

Partly right

Research says

Carrots contain beta-carotene, which the body turns into vitamin A. Vitamin A is needed to see in dim light, and a deficiency can cause night blindness.

But if you already have enough vitamin A, more carrots will not improve your sight. The myth got an extra push during the Second World War. During the bombing of London in 1940–41 the British spread the story that their pilots saw so well in the dark because they ate carrots. The real reason was radar, which was to be kept secret.

Grandma said

“Honey helps a cough”

Holds up quite well

Research says

A Cochrane review from 2018 found that honey probably relieves cough in children better than no treatment and placebo, and about as well as some cough medicines. The evidence is of moderate quality.

Important: Never give honey to children under one year old. Honey can contain spores that cause botulism in infants. If a cough lasts a long time, or the child is listless or has trouble breathing, contact a doctor.

Grandma said

“Take cod liver oil in winter”

Right

Research says

In winter the sun is too low in Norway for the skin to make enough vitamin D, so we have to get it from food. A teaspoon of cod liver oil, 5 ml, gives about 10 micrograms of vitamin D, the recommended daily intake for adults in Norway.

Oily fish such as salmon, herring and mackerel are also good sources. Recommendations can change, so check the latest advice from your health authorities.

Experience

Have advice we should check?

Send us advice you have inherited under inherited wisdom, and we will include it in the next round. The grandmother in Arvekraft is a nurse with a master’s degree in evidence-based practice, and she quality-checks everything we write about health.

The Moon Letter

Get the moon’s crystal, intention and ritual at every new and full moon.

Subscribe

Sources

  1. Science Norway: Where the carrot myth comes from
  2. Smithsonian Magazine: A WWII propaganda campaign popularized the myth that carrots help you see in the dark
  3. Cochrane: Honey for acute cough in children
  4. NHI: Slik får du nok vitamin D